Sayonara, Eudora, ohayo-gozaimasu Pmail
I have been using Eudora email clients since my Macintosh SE days, so it's no small deal for me to be changing email clients. Why change after nearly two decades of use?
Things I love to hate about you, dora. I purchased Eudora 4.1 for Windows and subsequent upgrades, yet the program insists on asking me to register over and over again. It periodically asks me to reveal my user behavior. It processes hyperlinks badly (a symptom that has persisted from Windows NT through XP, on five computers). Filters have always been non-intuitive and clunky.
Never can say goodbye? For years, I've found excuses for not trading in or trading up. Version 4.3.2 supports whatever version of PGP I use, and I use the version that works with the folks in my keyring. I have a filter set, clunky and overly long, that mostly works. I know every power key. I know nearly all the files in the Eudora folder, and what I don't know about the .ini file, I can learn quickly from my colleague Fred Avolio or my partner, Lisa. I can resurrect folders from 1994 (if the floppies are still readable), the mail looks as if it's just arrived. I should be sittin' fat and happy, right?
Familiarity breeds contempt. For all that versions 4, 5, and 6 purport to have changed, they haven't really changed. I downloaded the trialware for each major version, and despite new skins and "new" features, it's still pretty much the same Eudora I've launched every day. I'm still using 4.3.2 because trial after trial, I just didn't see anything sexy or edgy enough to make me want to buy the new software, buy the PGP that works with it.
I realize that I still have that "email clients should be free" mentality that first attracted me to Eudora. Somewhere on the Internet, there must be some client that does what Eudora does, and is more secure.
What I found was David Harris' Pegasus Mail (Pmail). I've use it for only 24 hours, but am already very comfortable with it, largely because it's enough like Eudora in ways I find important, and different or better in features I found lacking in Eudora. For "unencumbered and free" it's a very complete piece of software. It installed cleanly, and didn't require a restart (always earns a smiley face). It's got a familiar and intuitive user interface, similar to Eudora in many respects. Filter creation is (for me) more intuitive than Eudora. Spam and content protection are built-in. Pmail has a shared-secret based email security for bulk encryption and digital signing, and it supports PGP. Fancy email editing includes font styles, ttables, picture insert, hyperlink embedding. Pmail client is also an LDAP, Finger, and PH clients. It has distribution list support, and works with Norton AntiVirus. And several folks have gone to the trouble of creating address and Eudora mail folder import utilities. It's also a much smaller executable than Eudora.
Pegasus mail is public service software. It's traditional Internet, with non-official support and FAQ sites, and developers who create plug-ins and interact on mail lists. It's community-ware, like the early versions of Eudora...
Still too early to tell, but pmail looks like a keeper. I'll keep you posted.
Archived at http://www.securityskeptic.com/arc20040801.htm#BlogID290
by Dave Piscitello